Cam for S-Jax and Schaub? WHIR

[Eightan]

I'm trading Cam and getting Schaub and S-Jax. I'm currently 5-2 and the other team is 1-6, partly due to bad luck. Although I'm trading away the best player in this deal, I'm tempted because getting S-Jax would give me 3 solid backs to start every week going forward, to go with my solid WR core. Also, the Schaub to Andre connection is tempting as well. I just hesitate to trade Cam because he's just so good! What do you guys think?

10 team league, standard scoring, except 4 pts for passing TD's, non-PPR

QB- Cam Newton
WR- Andre Johnson
WR- Calvin Johnson
WR- V. Cruz
RB- Murray
RB- Moreno
TE- Graham
W/R/T- Bernard Scott
Def- NYG
K- Bailey
BN- Ingram, Beanie, Hardesty, Blount, Jenkins

[SF2313]

I'm trading Cam and getting Schaub and S-Jax. I'm currently 5-2 and the other team is 1-6, partly due to bad luck. Although I'm trading away the best player in this deal, I'm tempted because getting S-Jax would give me 3 solid backs to start every week going forward, to go with my solid WR core. Also, the Schaub to Andre connection is tempting as well. I just hesitate to trade Cam because he's just so good! What do you guys think?

10 team league, standard scoring, except 4 pts for passing TD's, non-PPR

QB- Cam Newton
WR- Andre Johnson
WR- Calvin Johnson
WR- V. Cruz
RB- Murray
RB- Moreno
TE- Graham
W/R/T- Bernard Scott
Def- NYG
K- Bailey
BN- Ingram, Beanie, Hardesty, Blount, Jenkins

I think with Blount, Ingram, Beanie I would not take this deal. Stay put. Cam will continue to put up monster numbers. If anything package 1-2 of your RBs on your bench and/or Murray and go after a decent WR/DEF. Blount and Wells should be back soon. Hold tight!

[dhballday]

Yeah I agree, Blount will get more snaps because Graham is on the IR. Just ride Murry until Beanie comes back.

[DVauthrin]

i'd sit tight. with passing td's worth only 4 points, newton is much more valuable than schaub.

[Weasel_King]

i'd sit tight. with passing td's worth only 4 points, newton is much more valuable than schaub.

This. Newton's value is much higher in this league, and S-Jax is not worth the downgrade from Newton to Schaub.

Help on mine?
viewtopic.php?f=19&t=505835

[sabomnim]

agreed...sjax value just isnt that high
stick with cam

please help
viewtopic.php?t=505848

[moses5488]

Stick with Cam. He's especially better since passing TDs are lower than usual and Cam likes to run em in himself anyways.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=505851