I give Ray Rice & Big Ben - I Get Drew Brees, Andre Johnson, Demarco Murray
Current Starting Lineup QB: Rothlisberger/Romo RB: Ray Rice RB: LeSean McCoy RB/WR: Shonn Green WR: V-Jax WR: Reggie Wayne/V-Cruz/Heyward-Bey
1. He sent me Brees & Mike Wallace for Big Ben & LeSean McCoy 2. I sent Romo, Rice, & Jacobs for Brees, Andre, & Murray 3. He sent the current trade
Should I make It?
So its basically the same trade but you keep what I think is the better QB, and get the same 3 guys you wanted? yeah, I think you do it, Brees is great, Romo you can trade, and you need Andre but have some depth to wait for him. Seems like you're giving less to get the deal you wanted..
I dont think its a no-brainer, I love the Rice/McCoy combo. You do need help at WR, but andre is likely out this week and with the Texans on bye in 11, no lock to be back week 10 either. Brees is an upgrade, but I think Romo is fine and Big Ben will have some weeks where he has great matchups too.
all said, you are getting the guys you wanted, IMO for less then what you countered him with. I like the trade if you're looking ahead to the playoffs, Brees is a beast, 2nd to Rivers this year, and Andre will be back week 12 IMO and greatly improves your WR's for a playoff run. Murray has looked more the primary back then Felix ever has, and I wouldnt be suprised at all if Murray kept the starting job even with Felix back.