Trade AJ for Murray? WHIR

[saemick]

I'm in a keeper league and it appears that I will probably miss the playoffs, so I'm looking for next year.

I can trade for:

DeMarco Murray - can be kept for a 12th round pick in 2012

for

Andre Johnson - can NOT be kept

here's my current roster:

QB: Eli, Freeman
RB: Foster, Blount, Ingram, Pierre Thomas, Best, Tate, Carter
WR: A.J. Green, Dez Bryant, AJ, Mike Williams (TB) Ford, DHB
TE: A. Hernandez
K: Gostkowski
D: DET

do I make this trade?

leave a link

[Norsouh]

I would say take it. Demarco Murray has looked really good thus far, however it is important to note, that throughout his career he has always been plagued by injury.

Despite this,I would say make the deal. From what I can understand, even if you make it to the playoffs you won't go far, so trading for next year makes more sense.

Could you check mine out?
viewtopic.php?t=508362

[tapionminoshi]

For SURE. Murray is performing like a top 5 back, and after 4 weeks, i'm sold. I'd do this deal even if you didn't have the giant bonus of securing a top 5 back for free next year. go click accept trade now please.

help w/ mine:
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=508368

[McDuff]

regardless of situation I would say this is a good trade. And for next year you are looking great with a top back in the 12th round
I would say your chances of making the playoffs this year are better with Murray than AJ.
I'll assume this was also before you heard about the Shaub injury.
How do you feel about Matt Lienart throwing to your guy?