Palmer vs. Manning... am I nuts even asking??

[jfin66]

Picked up Palmer a few week ago and he's been riding my pine.
Have had Eli at QB1 for weeks now (Fitzpatrick my QB2), and has been really good.

First week of playoffs, and now thinking about starting Palmer against GB, who is giving up the most QB pts in the league.
Manning is going against a tough Dallas DEF, who gives up the 24th most pts (or is it 21st?) to league QBs.

What I'm thinking is Palmer will always be throwing in this game and should have monster numbers. But worried about fatigue and whether or not he'll perform.

What do you think? Should I play it safe with Eli?

[Skyndalive]

I would agree with you if D Moore and J Ford were playing.

I think I'd have to go with the guy that got you to the playoffs.

Good luck!

[munstermann]

Palmer is a throwing machine. Remember 3 years back when he had a7 TD, 500 yard game against the browns? He is not going to tire. He's going to be throwing his heart out in an attempt to keep pace i would imagine. Go with Palmer. Good luck

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=510261

[mattbrennan1]

They are my two qb's and I like Palmer but Manning has been really good this year, he's Aaron Rodgers with 2 turnovers.