To me the only fair thing is a coin flip. Then you guys need to add some tiebreakers to your rules for next year. Possibly have every team pick 1 teibreaker player. Then maybe starters TDs scored.
12 Team 1/2 PPR Dynasty Auction League.
QB: Cutler, Hill
RB: Turner,Slaton,Benson,Mendenhall,Harrison,Robinson, Greene
WR: CJ2, Fitz, Smith(NYG), Brunce, Morgan,Bryant