Who Should I keep in a 0.5 PPR League?

[rmsanger]

Here are my options and what I would give up, would appreciate your input:

AP - 1st round
Vick - 2nd round
Run DMC - 3rd round
Dez Bryant - 4th round
Gates - 5th Round
Brandon Lloyd - 6th round

Waiver Pickups:

Matt Ryan - 9th
Peyton Hillis - 9th
Santonio Holmes

[Indibuck]

How many do you have to keep?

[rmsanger]

We can only keep 1 or none in a 10 team league.

[Indibuck]

I guess it depends on when you have to declare keepers, but at this present time, I don't see a lot of value for any of your players. Maybe DMac if Bush isn't back in OAK. Maybe Lloyd for a 6th. But there just isn't any tremendous value for anyone.... I would likely throw them all back and start again.

[rmsanger]

Yeah, I had the same feeling but we do have to report now (this week). My brain says to not keep anyone but everyone else in the league already has a keeper so I know at least 9 other players off the board.

Was thinking AP might be an ok value if my picks was at the end of round 1... Run DMC should be great but he can't stay healthy... I'm done with Vick. The rest are just fodder as I'm not sure Dez is worth a 4th.

[mariners100]

I would pass on Vick and AP for sure. The only guy that I would consider is DMC, even with injuries he is still worth a 3rd round pick. I would look at taking Bush though too in the draft too just to be safe.

[rmsanger]

One last update... I can keep only 1 but can do the followng:

Keep McFadden and give up a 3rd
Keep Dez and give up a 5th
Keep Matt Ryan and give up a 9th
Keep nobody