Michael Vick-Dynasty Trade

[illad3lph]

I am in a 12 team PPR dynasty league. Do you think I should trade Vick straight up for Dez Bryant? I think Vick could have a huge year after being the biggest bust, but Dez is youn witha lot of upside. What do you think? Here is my roster:


Player YTD Pts Bye
Flynn, Matt GBP QB 50.32 8
Manning, Eli NYG QB 318.78 7
Vick, Michael PHI QB 265.38 7

Bell, Kahlil CHI RB 71.70 8
Forte, Matt CHI RB (I) 221.30 8
Johnson, Chris TEN RB 225.40 6
McCoy, LeSean PHI RB 326.80 7
McGahee, Willis DEN RB 167.20 6
McKnight, Joe NYJ RB 39.90 8
Redman, Isaac PIT RB 89.20 11
Ringer, Javon TEN RB (I) 70.60 6

Breaston, Steve KCC WR 152.10 6
Collie, Austin IND WR 109.50 11
Gaffney, Jabar WAS WR 191.90 5
Heyward-Bey, Darrius OAK WR 184.10 8
Johnson, Calvin DET WR (P) 358.10 9
Knox, Johnny CHI WR (I) 120.00 8
Manningham, Mario NYG WR 113.80 7
Moore, Lance NOS WR (O) 163.30 11
Tate, Golden SEA WR 91.10 6

Cook, Jared TEN TE 141.00 6
Gronkowski, Rob NEP TE 328.30 7
Keller, Dustin NYJ TE 175.40 8

Kasay, John NOS PK 147.00 11

Texans, Houston HOU Def 95.00 11
25 Total Players

Injured Reserve
Charles, Jamaal KCC RB (I) 18.00 6
Amendola, Danny STL WR (I) 9.00 5
2 Total Players

[VIKINGFAN]

I like this deal for you......You could use another STUD WR, opposite Megatron, but I also believe Vick should net you a little more in return......then just Dez alone.
QB's should be worth more then a WR. You should be fine with Eli, and Flynn should catch on somewhere this offseason. Don't expect numbers like he put up vs the Lions (last game of the season) every week. Still he should be a serviceable QB.

[11stever11]

I like the trade for you. Your QBs are fine as I like Eli Manning more than Vick due to Vicks injury risk. Dez Bryant has huge upside and can be a top 10 WR for years to come.

[onepunch]

Do it. You have Eli. I BELIEVE in Eli, except this w/e against my Packers, of course.

[Indibuck]

Yeah I agree with the others... I think this helps your squad, especially with what you will have left at QB.

[UnitedFive]

This will help your squad as with everyone else I would go ahead with it I had Vick in my regular season and I had to pickup a backup QB and got stuck with Carson Palmer because of Vicks injury to his ribs.. I don't like Vicks injury potential so I would def go ahead with this trade an on the flipside you do have Eli as Flynn is an awesome backup and I foresee him going far and he would def someone to hang onto after this year aswell he may get a deal for another team as a starter or you never know what could happen!

[MadDog36]

Yeah Flynn will end up as a starter somewhere. He's too good. Hmm, wonder where he'd end up.

You can always spend a rookie/FA draft pick on a backup QB or rookie QB who will start. Guys like Jake Locker, Kyle Orton, Carson Palmer, Christian Ponder, Colt McCoy might be available? In fact who is in FA (look deeply).