Keeper Question

[TheWarlock187]

I have to keep 4 of these players (no more then 2 at one position) scoring is 60% TD 40% YDS

QBS - P Manning, E Manning
RBS - F Gore, A Bradshaw, R Mathews
WRS - G Jennings, B Marshall, AJ Green

Thank you for any help you provide, and if you leave a link I will help out on your topic!

[Shark1225]

Seems pretty easy choices to me:

RB: Mathews, Gore
WR: Green, Jennings

It'll be hard throwing back the Mannings but there are 15-20 QB's who you could argue will have a better 2012 than either one.

[Jason497]

Since it's Non-PPR I guess I'd go with Jennings over Marshall, but that's very close.

QB: Peyton Manning
RB: Mathews
WR: Jennings/AJ Green

[Those About To Rock]

I agree with the 2nd poster, but I'd keep P. Manning on the radar for some midround action, I think his upside for value is pretty decent from what I've seen.

[TruNinerFan]

Eli, Mathews, AJ, Jennings

[11stever11]

QB-Peyton Manning
RB-Mathews
WR-Marshall and Jennings

[Indibuck]

Eli, Mathews, AJ, Jennings

+1

[snixx79]

You are going to get all sorts of answers here.....if you start 3 wrs id lean towards Matthews/Aj/Marshall/Jennings, Tough to let Eli go (yes id keep him over Peyton), but i feel you can get a decent starter in the redraft if everyone can only keep 4. Those 3 wrs are crazy if u can start 3. If u start 2, keep Eli, let one of Jennings/Marshall go. (Flip a coin!) Jennings in better situation, elite QB, but a ton of weapons to steal looks. Marshall reunited with Cutler and a strong run game....both will be solid. I have them back to back in my rankings, Marshall slightly ahead.