Rank these Keepers: Nicks, Roddy, DMC

[jmkratt]

How would you rank these players as prospective keepers? 6pts all TDs, 0.1pt/yard:

H. Nicks
R. White
Darren McFadden

I can choose one.

Thank you

[Indibuck]

Nicks
McFadden
White

[K0wned]

McFadden
Nicks
White

Help me?
viewtopic.php?t=513664

[Those About To Rock]

RunDMC -- He'll get injured, but 'if' he doesn't his ceiling is so high
White -- He won't have the slump he did last year, Julio came on too strong at the end to dedicate double coverage to White every play
Nicks -- The NYG receiving corps is like a lottery. Each year Eli chooses one to be the guy, and I don't like gambles

[murphysxm]

McFadden
Nicks
White

i agree with this. DMac's ceiling is so much higher than the WR's.

[dagnuk]

1. Mcfadden: Could be the top player at his position with his combined talent and projected workload, if he stays healthy.
2. Roddy White
3. Nicks: Ranking White higher is just my personal preference concerning these two players, based on Nicks' offseason injuries.

[Indibuck]

McFadden
Nicks
White

i agree with this. DMac's ceiling is so much higher than the WR's.

But the floor is so much lower. Just sayin'.

[TruNinerFan]

Nicks
McFadden
White

I agree