Should I not do this???

[amarlls]

I offered Cam newton and Jordy nelson for Michael Turner and Calvin Johnson?


Active Offense
Newton, Cam(QB) CAR
Bush, Reggie(RB) MIA
McFadden, Darren(RB) OAK
Cruz, Victor(WR) NYG
Nelson, Jordy(WR) GB
Helu, Roy(RB) WAS
Keller, Dustin(TE) NYJ
Raiders(DST) OAK
Carpenter, Dan(K) MIA

Griffin III, Robert(QB) WAS
Starks, James(RB) GB
Ford, Jacoby(WR) OAK
Moore, Denarius(WR) OAK
Robinson, Laurent(WR) JAC

[crudelamens]

thanks for mine.
Ya I would reconsider. not sure of your scoring but that would leave you awfully thin and vulnerable at QB

[amarlls]

The only thing I thought of was trading few guys for a nice QB but I agree

[dagnuk]

If you're trading Cam away, then you'd better have a better qb option than Griffin. I wouldn't trade Cam away until you KNOW what you can get to replace him.

[northernpackfan]

I wouldn't do that deal if I was you. Newton did what no other rookie QB had ever done, so I doubt RGIII replicates the performance the very next year. If RGIII does explode out of the gate, you'll always be able to move Newton a couple of weeks into the season.

[FantasySportsMaven]

No, no no... don't do that deal.
Newton is worth more than that with Nelson thrown in.
I think Newton/Nelson/Helu or Bush >> RG3/Calvin/Turner.

Help me in return? viewtopic.php?f=18&t=513810

[amarlls]

If I can get Vick for my Bush and Laurent should I maybe consider the deal?

[11stever11]

If I can get Vick for my Bush and Laurent should I maybe consider the deal?

I would make that trade but I would still pass on this deal. You need to get a better player in return than Turner

[Those About To Rock]

I think Turner is going to slow down this year and strongly disapprove of this trade.

[Guru13]

Is this a redraft? If so the deal's not quite as bad but I'd still definitely pass. Turner is gonna struggle I think and the Madden Curse is nothing to mess around with if you can avoid it.