Compare these two rosters

[Mizou]

Did a mock draft for a 12-team redraft league, which is similar to what my friend is putting together later this summer. How does this stack up against the roster I drafted for an earlier (10-team) league?

Edit: Forgot, both are standard scoring (4pt pass td) leagues. Non-PPR, non keeper, etc.

12-team

QB: E. Manning, Andy Dalton
RB: Trent Richardson, Fred Jackson, Michael Bush, CJ Spiller, Toby Gerhart
WR: Fitzgerald, Miles Austin, Reggie Wayne, Robert Meachem, Michael Floyd
TE: Jermichael Finley
K: Robbie Gould
D/ST: Dallas

--------------------

Older 10-team roster

QB: Brees
RB: Turner, Sproles, Isaac Redman, Beanie Wells, Benjarvis Green-Ellis, James Starks, Toby Gerhart
WR: Roddy White, Jordy Nelson, Antonio Brown, Jeremy Maclin, Torrey Smith,
TE: Gronkowski
K: Mike Nugent
D/ST: Houston

[11stever11]

I like your 10-team roster with the top 5 QB and top 5 TE. The only problem is that your running backs are a little weak especially in non-PPR. The 12 team roster is a good but does not have the overall depth like the 10 team roster. I like that you grabbed Wayne who I think is a solid WR3. I am not a fan of Fred Jackson but having Spiller on the roster helps.

[Mizou]

I like your 10-team roster with the top 5 QB and top 5 TE. The only problem is that your running backs are a little weak especially in non-PPR. The 12 team roster is a good but does not have the overall depth like the 10 team roster. I like that you grabbed Wayne who I think is a solid WR3. I am not a fan of Fred Jackson but having Spiller on the roster helps.

I was trying a different philosophy with the 12-team mock (the more common ideal of taking the best RBs you can, and failing that, WRs), as opposed to the QB/TE method in the 10-team.

In the real 12-man, would you suggest sticking to the RB/WR philosophy, or doing something similar to what I did earlier and locking up QB, then maybe TE/starting in on the WR/RB? This of course hinges on draft position, as top 3 picks would be the top 3 RBs.

[11stever11]

I like your 10-team roster with the top 5 QB and top 5 TE. The only problem is that your running backs are a little weak especially in non-PPR. The 12 team roster is a good but does not have the overall depth like the 10 team roster. I like that you grabbed Wayne who I think is a solid WR3. I am not a fan of Fred Jackson but having Spiller on the roster helps.

I was trying a different philosophy with the 12-team mock (the more common ideal of taking the best RBs you can, and failing that, WRs), as opposed to the QB/TE method in the 10-team.

In the real 12-man, would you suggest sticking to the RB/WR philosophy, or doing something similar to what I did earlier and locking up QB, then maybe TE/starting in on the WR/RB? This of course hinges on draft position, as top 3 picks would be the top 3 RBs.

I would go running back in the first round unless you can get Rodgers if you are in the 1.04 or 1.05 spot. Then I would go QB in the second round so you can lock up a top 5 QB or RB if you get Rodgers. In the mocks I have done I find myself going RB/QB/WR/WR/WR/WR in the first six rounds than taking a couple of McGahee/Spiller type running backs. I think that the tight end position is deep enough that you do not need to take Gronk and Graham. Olsen, Celek and Tamme are guys I like later in drafts. The QB/TE strategy works better in the 10 team league from what I have seen, since doing QB/TE makes you have a guy like Turner as your RB1. Hope this helps

[bigdogg712]

well obviously the 10 team roster is better than the 12. I don't really like richardson this year. He plays stout defenses in 6 of his 16 games. Your WRS are great in both leagues, but I like your RBs in the 10 teamer.

[Zbetty]

Both are solid rosters. The one thing I would try to improve on is getting a true #1 back on both teams. Not saying you couldn't win with what you have because many of them are consistent point scores but you don't have the huge game guy.