Pick 3

[myke612]

12 team .5ppr
What order would you rank these 3 wr for 2012?

Brandon Marshall
Greg Jennings
Roddy White
Andre Johnson

I can keep 3 and the cost would be the same regardless of the 3 I keep so how would you rank them for this year?

[Stevooo]

1. AJ
2. Jennings
3. Roddy
4. Marshall

I think AJ and Jennings are locks and the last spot is up to you and how you feel about thier situations. I would take em how I have em listed. good luck.

[Cowboys 4 life]

Roddy
AJ
Jennings
Marshall

[thefantasytutor]

This is a pretty good problem to have! You have 3 WR1s here. My lengthy response would be to take Greg Jennings as your #1. If you feel like gambling on the oft-injured Andre Johnson, then go ahead and keep him too. Personally I don't feel like gambling on Johnson this year, I owned him last year and it completely sucked. If you want to play it safe: keep Jennings, Roddy and Marshall. If you feel like gambling a bit, keep Jennings, Andre and whoever you like better Roddy/Marshall. Personally I like Roddy just a little bit more than I like Marshall, but they are very close.

If it were me, I'd keep Jennings, Roddy and Marshall.

Is there any way you can trade one of these guys to make your decision a little bit easier? Just throw it out there that you will trade one of those 4 receivers and see what you get.

mod edit - removal of web advertisement

[Wood Chipper]

Drop AJ

The other 3 are consistent and are less likely to be injured.

[Zbetty]

Jennings
Roddy
AJ
Marshall
All are solid picks. I rank them this way because consistency is huge. Would you prefer a player that gets you 30 points one week and 5 the next or the player that will get you 15 to 20 every week? Greg is as consistent as they come. There is talk Roddy will get less looks with Jolio there, but he is still a lock for around 80 grabs. AJ has the most potential but is a health risk. Marshall I see doing well but Forte is still the centerpeice of the offense.

[LMack]

For me the drop is Marshall. I think Andre Johnson's return to 2009-2010 numbers is more likely than Marshall regaining the form and report he had with Cutler in Denver.

[Jason497]

I like Roddy, AJ, and Jennings. I think if it was a full 1PPR I might lean towards Marshall over Jennings but in 0.5 I'll probably still lead towards Jennings since he's a lock for 10-12 TDs as long as he stays healthy. Roddy White is just a machine and when AJ is healthy he is easily top 3 with Megatron and Fitz. He's so undervalued because the hamstring last year but 2008-2010 he only missed 3 games so I think his health thing is slightly overblown.

[TruNinerFan]

I would drop jennings. You could make a case for keeping all these guys, but I would drop Jennings just due to the fact that Green Bay has so many weapons. i think jennings will see the least amount of targets out of these guys. But, I understand that andre is very risky because of his injury history.

If you want to gamble keep: AJ, Roddy, marshall

If you want to play it safe keep: Roddy, marshall, jennings

[BurritoBoy]

I rank them:

Jennings
AJ
White
Marshall

Andre's injury history is enough to move him down, and Nelson's numbers will go down, and I think a lot of those numbers will go to Jennings. I like White over Marshall as well.