Hakeem Nicks or Julio Jones

[bradleyk]

I drafted Julio Jones and a friend offered Hakeem Nicks for him. I had Julio Jones higher (#8 vs #10) on my big board, but now that I think about it, Manningham leaving might affect Nicks more than I thought. Plus Stephanie Bell seems sold that Nicks will be healthier by week one.

12 team. One point for one reception. I also have Jeremy Maclin and Mike Williams along with a few late round fliers.

Thanks.

[11stever11]

I prefer Julio Jones. I think he has a little more upside and less of an injury risk.

[dagnuk]

All things being equal, just look at Nicks' past, and you'll see that he lands on the injury report every week. He's a headache worth avoiding, especially when the price is a potentially better WR like Julio Jones. Honestly, when you're looking at 2 guys ranked this close to each other, if you're trading away the healthy player, you're not winning the trade.

[Jason497]

I prefer Julio Jones. I think he has a little more upside and less of an injury risk.

I feel the same way.

[bradleyk]

Thanks guys. I appreciate the help, and I'll be keeping Julio Jones.

[GeneralTsou]

Do you guys think Julio will be around at pick 19?

[BurritoBoy]

I like Julio Jones, but it is very close.

[TruNinerFan]

I prefer Julio. he is going to blow up this year