Is this a fair trade?

[JETS]

Hey Guys,

It is a 12 team league.
We have 1 QB, 2 RBs, 3 WRs, 1 TE, 2 Flex , 1K, 1 DST

I am giving up Juilo Jones, Darren Sproles, and Mark Ingram, in return I would get Roddy White, Ahmad Bradshaw, and BenJarvus Green-Ellis.

Is this a fair trade?

[btsoumas]

I like this trade. Julio and Roddy will both be comparable and it will be a coinflip on who scores more in a given week. I'm not high on anyone in the New Orleans backfield. Bradshaw will get his touches along with BJGE who will also get plenty of goalline carries. Pull the trigger.

[snixx79]

If this is a seasonal league, not keeper, i think its a fair deal.....pros and cons on both sides.

I feel Julio is the best player in the trade, though Roddy is not far behind.
I have reservations about Sproles/Ingram, with no coach, who knows how that goes....just keep in mind if it goes well, Sproles is good for 1200 total yds and 7tds.
Bradshaw (if healthy) should be a top end RB2 and could push 10+ tds....health being the only concern, (if he goes down, Wilson may not give the job back)
BJGE-great value and a good buy low, an RB3 with little risk that could put up rb2 numbers.

All in all risk on both ends...in the end id rather have the trio of Roddy/Bradshaw/Law Firm in my starting than Julio/Sproles/Ingram.

[angels7777]

give me Julio side every time

viewtopic.php?t=515271

[spread eagles]

roddy, amad, bjge for the win