Is this a good trade?

[Blaze132]

I give: Steve Johnson (Bills) and Doug Baldwin

I get: Brandon Marshall and Mario Manningham


Scoring:
1 point per 25 passing yards
4 points per passing td
1 point per 10 rushing yards
6 points per rushing td
-2 for interceptions
-2 fumble lost

QB: Aaron Rodgers,Eli Manning, Matt Cassel
RB: Steven Jackson, Marshawn Lynch, Joe McKnight, Cedric Benson, Mike Tolbert
WR: Wes Welker, Steve Johnson, Kenny Britt, Brandon Lloyd, Danny Amendola, Doug Baldwin, Justin Blackmon
TE: Vernon Davis
K: Matt Prater

DL: Kamerion Wimbley, Trent Cole, Mathias Kiwanuka
LB: Sean Weatherspoon, Daryl Washington, D'Qwell Jackson, James Anderson
DB: Thomas DeCoud, Jarrius Byrd, Antrel Rolle, Yeremiah Bell

[dblj9911]

Hit accept now and be happy, quick, quick quick!!!!! For Marshall alone I would do it, Manningham is thrown in is somewhat of a bonus. I do like S. Johnoson, but he isn't as good a wr as Marshall, and the Mann / Baldwin is a wash. Good luck.

viewtopic.php?t=515300

[BurritoBoy]

You get the best player in the deal, and you get another end-of-the-bench-could-break-out kind of guy in Manningham for Baldwin.

I like the trade

[TruNinerFan]

I would do it. Marshall is the best player in the deal