McFadden for Vick and Kevin Smith? Will answer yours

[chud214]

I'm in an unlimited keeper league where for every player you keep, you slip one round in the draft. I have Andy Dalton and Carson Palmer as my 2 QBs, and my top RBs are McFadden, Marshawn Lynch and Michael Turner. I also have Tim Hightower just in case Shanahan goes with the right guy. LOL I've been offered Michael Vick and Kevin Smith for McFadden. All 3 players have past issues dealing with injuries, but I've got to admit to having a man-crush on McFadden, more specifically his potential. Do you think it's worth the deal in order to upgrade at the QB position?

[PackFan23]

Keep McFadden. When Vick gets hurt and your stuck with your same QBs, you'll thank me.

[murphysxm]

NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

When healthy, McFadden has potential for #1 RB overall. Vick isn't getting younger and Smith is a fill in player

[spread eagles]

Agree with what they said.

[dagnuk]

Keep McFadden. Kevin Smith is a place-holder. He's going to have his 2 biggest games in weeks 1-2, when Leshoure is suspended. I don't expect to hear his name much beyond that.