Trade Offer for Matthews

[TheLeagueChamp]

This is a 12 Team Dynasty with IDP non-PPR.

Passing Yards 20 yards per point; 1 points at 300 yards; 2 points at 350 yards; 3 points at 400 yards
Passing Touchdowns 6
Interceptions -2
Rushing Yards 10 yards per point; 1 points at 100 yards; 2 points at 150 yards; 3 points at 200 yards
Rushing Touchdowns 6
Reception Yards 10 yards per point; 1 points at 100 yards; 2 points at 150 yards; 3 points at 200 yards
Reception Touchdowns 6
Return Yards 25 yards per point 0
Return Touchdowns 6
2-Point Conversions 2
Fumbles Lost -2
Offensive Fumble Return TD 6
Pick Sixes Thrown -4




So I was offered Miles Austin, SJax, and Gore for Nicks and Matthews. I feel like I should counter so I brought this to the Cafe.

My Team

Romo QB
Jennings WR
Nicks WR
Blackmon WR
Matthews RB
Turner RB
Gates TE
Finley W/R/T
Redman W/R/T

Bench:

Mike Williams
Fitzpatrick
Jacobs
David Nelson
Doucet
Weeden
Heath Miller


His Team

Ryan QB
Green WR
Austin WR
Colston WR
C. Johnson RB
Steven Jackson RB
Fred Davis TE
J. Charles W/R/T
A. Bradshaw W/R/T

Bench (He has a larger bench because he has no IDP bench)

AP
Bowe
Gore
Locker
A. Smith
Jared Cook
Starks
R. Randle
Fleener
L. Robinson
A. Jeffrey



What do you guys think? Take it? Counter? Reject? Let me Know

[TheLeagueChamp]

bump

[LSUby50]

i would not take it. you dont want those old farts on your team. if you could somehow pick up Charles or an upgrade over Blackmon, id consider it, but not a downgrade at WR2, and adding 2 over the hill RBs

PS: speaking of old RBs. maybe try to unload Turner and Jacobs for some younger blood if you do counter. But i think thats what he's trying to do.

[LS2throwed]

I think that's a pretty bad offer. Mathews and Nicks are two young studs who could be cornerstones of a dynasty for a long time as a RB1 and WR1. All these guys he's giving you are old except for Austin who is constantly injured and already battling more hamstring issues. I wouldn't suggest trading both of those guys together anyway, he has some nice young players on the team don't let him ship off those guys who have a year left of good play(Gore may not even have that, he was basically invisible to me in this deal as he does nothing for your team).


If he just wants Mathews try something like Adrian Peterson and Bowe for Mathews. At least as a starting point. If your moving Mathews then Steven Jackson and Gore don't need to be anything more then throw in players, not players who are the primary parts of the deal. I see no benefit what so ever to packaging building blocks like Mathews and Nicks together though.

[TheLeagueChamp]

Thanks guys and I figured this was a no brainer. Just wanted to see other thoughts. I countered AP and Bowe for Matthews so we will se how that plays out.