2 QB League Pre Draft Day Trade

[Giants25]

So I have the 8th pick in a 10 team, 2 QB, .5PPR League

Obviously QB's are important and I feel like getting 1 of the Elite guys is very important.

Do you think it would be dumb to make this trade?

I give away 8, 13, and my 8th round pick

I receive 4, 17, and his 10th round pick

My thought is I could get either one of Brady or Brees and definitely Stafford at pick 4. I know for a fact ARodge, Brady, Brees, Stafford and Cam will all go before pick 8. Basically, is the difference between that 8th round pick and 10th round pick enough to kill my team?

Help is appreciated. Thanks

[11stever11]

I would pass but it is close. I think you could get Matt Ryan at the eighth spot. He should have a top 5 finish this season with both White and Jones.

[dblj9911]

I'd go for it to get the upgrade at qb. There isn't much difference between the 8th or 10th Rd draft picks. So this comes down almost to the second round pick. To me the difference between the 13th and 17th isn't goingto be that great. Go for it, good luck.

[Quackman]

So I have the 8th pick in a 10 team, 2 QB, .5PPR League

Obviously QB's are important and I feel like getting 1 of the Elite guys is very important.

Do you think it would be dumb to make this trade?

I give away 8, 13, and my 8th round pick

I receive 4, 17, and his 10th round pick

My thought is I could get either one of Brady or Brees and definitely Stafford at pick 4. I know for a fact ARodge, Brady, Brees, Stafford and Cam will all go before pick 8. Basically, is the difference between that 8th round pick and 10th round pick enough to kill my team?

Help is appreciated. Thanks

With the information you know,,,that everyone is going qb early,,,another option you have is to do the opposite. If everyone goes QB you will get one of the top RB's (maybe even Rice?) or Megatron with the 8th pick. Id go RB again on your next pick. Id target qb's Matt ryan, Romo, Manning (either one). I like alex Smith this year and grab locker late for the bench.