What's up, Corey! Welcome to the Cafe.
As you know, I've been preferential to Foster, but I'm leaning towards Rodgers right now. It is such a sure thing, and my league awards 6 points per passing TD. I think this gives Rodgers a huge advantage over RBs. The potential is 40+ passing TDs to 17+ rushing/receiving TDs. Times each by 6 and add in 4,000 passing yards vs. 2000 all-purpose yards and Rodgers looks pretty good. Stomper...is it that simple or am I missing something?
The only other thing we have to factor in is who you will get at 24/25. Assuming you get Foster, you will have to hope Stafford is there or be happy with Eli Manning or M. Ryan later in the draft. WRs will be plentiful and in a 12-team league you can probably still get a White, Marshall, or Nelson. That sounds pretty good.
If you go with Rodgers, you have to get a RB or two and those are more iffy. At that spot, you could
see Martin, Mathews, Richardson and SJAX. If you are really luck, maybe some bigger names fall like Charles, Lynch, or Peterson.
Good luck! My draft is Sunday and I'm still undecided.