Opinions? 4th pick 12 team non ppr redraft

[Hogan]

Had the 4th pick. Standard league non ppr no flex. 1 pt per 25 pass yd, 10 yd rush, 10 yd rec. 6 pt per all td's. Start 1 QB, 2 RB, 3 WR, 1 TE, 1 K, 1 Def. Here's my squad. How did I do?

Qb-Vick,Schaub
RB-McCoy, Peterson, Hillis, Kevin Smith, Benson, Ben Tate
WR-Marshall,LLoyd,Torrey Smith,Randy Moss, amendola
TE-Tamme
K-Kaeding
Def-K.C

[WastelandENT]

QB: Vick can have a great year if he stays healthy and avoids turnovers, Schaub is a good QB2. I personally like having an elite QB on my teams, Brees/Rodgers/Brady.

RB: Amazing at this position, McCoy and Peterson are great ( how did you even get both of them?). Your depth at RB is also solid.

WR: Marshall and Lloyd should both have good year, solid WR1 and WR2 combo. Smith I like a lot, I think he is going to have a big year solid WR3 and if he has the year I think he will he will be a solid WR2. I am not to big on Moss or Amendola though.

TE: Tamme has upside but could be a risk. I would have rather had Hernandez or Finley.

D: I am not sure about KC but they shouldnt cost you any wins.

K: Kaeding is solid and will get the job done

Overall: A+ I think you have a great team here, McCoy and Peterson together is amazing. Your WR are also very good and should have big years. Vick at QB should be fine if he stays healthy.

Rate mine? http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=516449

[DukeVBall]

Drop Moss and go after Olsen or Rudolph for TE in case Tamme doesn't work out. I like Tamme but he's also competing against Dressen as well as indirectly against Thomas, Decker and Stokley.

Other than that, great squad!

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?f=44&t=516624

[teammajestic]

vick mccoy petersen is nice!!