So this guy offered me Greg Jennings for Hakeem Nicks. He drafted Jennings and Nelson by mistake so he said he wanted to trade one of them. Is it a good trade?
Heres my team:
QB: Rivers RB: Foster RB: Charles WR: Nicks WR: Julio Jones TE: Tamme RB/WR: Lloyd DST: Jets K: Prater
BN: Demaryaous Thomas BN: Britt BN: Wilson BN: Ingram BN: Hillis BN: Flacco BN: Ryan Williams
10 team no ppr
Im really leaning toward jennings, but so many people have brought up the fact that there are a ton of mouths to feed in GB. Jennings, Nelson, Jones, cobb, driver, finley, and benson! Thats what I'm worried about with Jennings. He does, however, have the talent to be the best WR in the league and he has the best QB in the league. In NY, Nicks and Cruz are the only mouths to feed by eli manning, however he has nagging injuries. Nicks, too, has the talent to be the best, but he doesn't have the best QB. Elis good, but rodgers is better. So, now that you know my concerns with both, can you help me make a decision?
********Also, Britt might be traded for ryan mathews. The guy I was talking to told me to send the trade, so I did, but it hasn't been accepted (or declined) yet
Last edited by bigdogg712 on Tue Aug 28, 2012 11:51 am, edited 4 times in total.
Honestly I have Nelson, Jennings, and Nicks about equal. I think Jennings is the highest upside / talent in the group, but that concussion injury makes me nervous. (Although Nicks is dealing with foot). Personally I think I take this trade, but don't expecta huge upgrade. Help me: viewtopic.php?f=18&t=516448
I don't think you can go wrong with either. I think Nicks has the higher ceiling but has a tougher time reaching it due to injury. I think Jennings is a tad safer. I'd take the trade.
I wouldn't do it. I agree with the other poster about the concussion concerns with Jennings and I think Nicks is actually more talented, although he has his own injury issues and doesn't have Rodgers throwing to him. Either way, Rodgers is more likely to spread it around while Nicks could be the focal point of that passing game.
I would definitely take Jennings over Nicks. Jennings is much safer and I think is going to have a better year than Nicks in general - not to mention Nicks' nagging injuries. Take the trade.
Help me out also: viewtopic.php?f=18&t=516446
10 team non PPR league
My team: QB: Brady RB: Rice RB: T. Rich WR:B. Marshall WR:D. Moore TE:Hernandez FX: Stewart D:Vikings K:Hanson
Bench: Freeman M. Bush Murray Britt Antonio Brown Gresham Keller
Im really leaning toward jennings, but so many people have brought up the fact that there are a ton of mouths to feed in GB. Jennings, Nelson, Jones, cobb, driver, finley, and benson! Thats what I'm worried about with Jennings. He does, however, have the talent to be the best WR in the league and he has the best QB in the league. In NY, Nicks and Cruz are the only mouths to feed by eli manning, however he has nagging injuries. Nicks, too, has the talent to be the best, but he doesn't have the best QB. Elis good, but rodgers is better. So, now that you know my concerns with both, can you help me make a decision?
seems like a lateral move to me.. but I do like Jennings, but Nicks I like about the same.. They are very close, so I would look at it like If you were drafting and had the choice of Nicks or Jennings(which you might have) who'd you take? if its Jennings make the deal, if you'd take Nicks then stay pat..
Cafe Home
Fantasy Baseball
Fantasy Basketball
Fantasy Hockey
by bigdogg712 » Mon Aug 27, 2012 12:06 am 
