vick, peyton or romo?

[miracles716]

who do i draft as my qb? my first 2 picks were foster and MJD.

[dblj9911]

For a redraft league I'm taking Peyton for the year. I like Romo but I really don't trust anyone on Dallas right now. Vick is going to miss some time, so he will put up points, but you will need a quality backup for him. Good luck.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=516478

[etl1692]

ROMO, great fantasy QB. Puts up numbers

[srlarson]

Manning.....I have manning in the 8-10 range for qb's...so bottom QB1....

Romo is a QB 12-15....bad team, bad line, bad WR......
Vick is inthe same range....if he doesn't run in TD's he isn't going to throw for a bunch..... so 12-15...both are backups

[SameSongNDance]

Tough choice here. A healthy Vick presents the most upside, but a healthy Vick seems to be rare. That coupled with the fact that you're forced to back him up with at least a decent option makes him an undesirable choice IMO.

Peyton will be efficient this year but extremely unexciting (reluctant to stretch the field). He's a low-end QB1 with minimal upside.

Romo, IMO, is the pick here. He has more upside than Peyton and is less of an injury risk than Vick. Dallas is a bit scary right now but Dez, Miles and Witten are getting healthier by the day. When he has his full set of compliments back, he'll put up more points than Peyton on a week to week basis while also being more durable than Vick.

[MMhawk607]

Romo definitely. He puts up really good numbers, his INTs are down. He can pass the ball well.

viewtopic.php?t=516495