oops! did I lose this trade?

[amarlls]

I give up witten and Ridley and I get Finley and Donald brown?

8 team keeper h2h 2qb

QB,"Griffin III, Robert(QB) WAS ",@NO,10,,0,312,31,62%,17%
QB,"Vick, Michael(QB) PHI ",@CLE,7,254,199,343.2,2,99%,73%
RB,"Foster, Arian(RB) HOU ",MIA,8,233,193,260.4,2,100%,95%
RB,"Richardson, Trent(RB) CLE ",PHI,10,,0,183.2,20,63%,53%
WR,"Fitzgerald, Larry(WR) ARI ",SEA,10,181,167,176.2,4,100%,99%
WR,"Johnson, Andre(WR) HOU ",MIA,8,53,137,176.8,21,100%,70%
WR,"Nicks, Hakeem(WR) NYG ",DAL,11,153,142,164,17,100%,95%
TE,"Witten, Jason(TE) DAL ",@NYG,5,115,121,109.2,31,100%,77%
RB-WR-TE,"Jackson, DeSean(WR) PHI ",@CLE,7,112,142,137.4,1,100%,74%
DST,49ers(DST) SF ,@GB,9,201,184,230.2,4,99%,91%
K,"Janikowski, Sebastian(K) OAK ",SD,5,143,122,126,14,98%,89%

Bench (QB),"Locker, Jake(QB) TEN ",NE,11,46,46,287.2,30,35%,2%
Bench (QB),"Palmer, Carson(QB) OAK ",SD,5,152,218,288.2,23,80%,16%
Bench (RB),"Ridley, Stevan(RB) NE ",@TEN,9,42,42,146.4,22,67%,28%
Bench (RB),"Stewart, Jonathan(RB) CAR ",@TB,6,131,127,120,32,93%,27%
Bench (RB-WR-TE),"Heyward-Bey, Darrius(WR) OAK ",SD,5,111,52,121.4,16,76%,18%
Bench (RB-WR-TE),"Meachem, Robert(WR) SD ",@OAK,7,90,102,124.8,25,79%,21%

[11stever11]

I think it is a fair trade. Witten may regress this season with the weapons in Dallas. I prefer Ridley over Brown though but you have good running back starters already.

[BoltSpeedman]

I like donald brown more then ridley and would render the TE's about even...Id say you got the better end of the deal



viewtopic.php?t=516751

[fatnub2339]

not at all.. Brown and Ridley both have similar potential in different situations, and Finley is a breakout candidate and an improvement from a declining witten. i think you got the better deal


[QUOTE=younguns87;34539599]lol I got two roles from two different people. They were not the same[/QUOTE]

[Stevooo]

I like this for you, but I like Brown this year.

[GraveDiggaz]

Love the trade, I prefer Finley over Witten and Brown over Ridley.

[colveraki]

Witten is one bad tackle from re-injuring his spleen. Finley has more upside, while Witten is on the downtrend. He had is heyday time to move onto Finely.

[midthunb]

Your starting lineup looks solid and Ridley would have been a bye week filler much like brown will be on your team. Comes down to who the better TE is and I believe it is Finley. A lot of mouths to feed in GB but Finley should be solid this year barring injury. Nice trade for you!

[TruNinerFan]

I really like that trade for you.

[BurritoBoy]

I like Finley over Witten by a bit, but I would rather have Ridley than Brown. Both are fairly similar though. I don't see a problem with this

viewtopic.php?t=516884