12 TM PPR QB M. Ryan, R. Fitzpatrick RB Demarco Murray, Doug Martin, Ryan Mathews, Donald Brown, Vick Ballard WR Calvin Johnson, Mike Wallace, Danny Amendola, James Jones TE Tony Gonzalez, Owen Daniels D Cards, Cowboys K Greg Zuerlein
I prefer David Wilson. I think that he will take carries away from Bradshaw and if Bradshaw gets hurt I think Wilson has RB2 upside. It is close though.
This is indeed close but I think Wilson's upside trumps Bush's here, especially in PPR. Bush is no slouch in the passing game, but he'll obviously, at the least, concede all 3rd-down duty to arguably the best pass catching RB in the league. Forte is also more durable than Bradshaw, the knee injury being a lot less serious than many people remember/believe. IMO, Bush may be the safer RB4 option week in week out but Wilson has much more long-term upside. I look for upside first and foremost in my RB4/5/6.
SameSongNDance wrote:This is indeed close but I think Wilson's upside trumps Bush's here, especially in PPR. Bush is no slouch in the passing game, but he'll obviously, at the least, concede all 3rd-down duty to arguably the best pass catching RB in the league. Forte is also more durable than Bradshaw, the knee injury being a lot less serious than many people remember/believe. IMO, Bush may be the safer RB4 option week in week out but Wilson has much more long-term upside. I look for upside first and foremost in my RB4/5/6.
I basically am looking at Bush as protecting my 2nd round pick. Straight up I prefer Wilson, but with Stewart, Brown, Spiller, etc. am I better taking the handcuff for Forte or stashing a bench player with upside? Not sure if you were looking at it from that angle.
10 tms .5 PPR, 6 pts for pass TD
QB- Rodgers WR- Marshall, Harvin, Bowe RB- Charles, Forte TE- A. Hernandez FLX- McGahee Def- Miami K- Bryant
BN- CJ Spiller, D. Moore, M. Bush, La. Moore, R. Jennings, T. Young
do you have roster restrictions on how many of each position you can have? if not take both and dump Santana Moss.. If you do, I think you should keep Bush just as a handcuff to Forte. If it was in a vacuum, I'd take Wilson, but since you own Forte, Bush.
prophecy135 wrote:do you have roster restrictions on how many of each position you can have? if not take both and dump Santana Moss.. If you do, I think you should keep Bush just as a handcuff to Forte. If it was in a vacuum, I'd take Wilson, but since you own Forte, Bush.
It would be a one for one trade... it was offered to me
10 tms .5 PPR, 6 pts for pass TD
QB- Rodgers WR- Marshall, Harvin, Bowe RB- Charles, Forte TE- A. Hernandez FLX- McGahee Def- Miami K- Bryant
BN- CJ Spiller, D. Moore, M. Bush, La. Moore, R. Jennings, T. Young
oh I thought it might be a WW move.. I really like Wilson, but not at the expense of losing the very capable back up to your #2 pick, not to mention Bush should get goal line work so he maybe a flex starter for you even with Forte healthy.
Cafe Home
Fantasy Baseball
Fantasy Basketball
Fantasy Hockey
by angels7777 » Wed Aug 29, 2012 5:03 pm 
