Who wins Week 1? WHIR

[jeloman]

Standard Scoring System. Passing TD's are only 4 points though. Bold names are the players being started.
Right now, Yahoo has me ahead by 4 projected points.

Leave your links below and I'll get to them as fast as I can.

My Team:
Cam Newton QB @TB
Jay Cutler QB vs. IND
Chris Johnson RB vs. NE
Trent Richardson RB vs. Phi
Darren Sproles RB vs. Was
Stevan Ridley RB @Ten
Ryan Williams RB vs. Sea
Jeremy Maclin WR @Cle
Dez Bryant WR @NYG
Torrey Smith WR vs. Cin
Nate Washington WR vs. NE
Jimmy Graham TE vs. Was
Jacob Tamme TE vs. Pit
Stephen Gostkowski K @Ten
Philadelphia DEF @Cle

His Team:
Eli Manning QB vs. Dal
Andy Dalton QB @Bal
Steven Jackson RB @Det
Michael Turner RB @KC
Ryan Matthews RB @Oak
Shonn Greene RB vs. Buf
Calvin Johnson WR vs. StL
Mike Wallace WR @Den
Miles Austin WR @NYG
Reggie Wayne WR @Chi
Robert Meachem WR @Oak
Laurent Robinson WR @Min
Brandon Pettigrew TE vs. StL
Nate Kaeding K @Oak
New York Giants DEF vs. Dal

[bounce]

I like your team to win. In a 4pt PA TD league, Cam has a big advantage over other QBs, because of his rushing.

Help me if you get a chance? viewtopic.php?t=516931

[fdeb35]

Not an overwhelming grouping at either RB or WR -- Dez is a gamble that you will need to pay off (as is Richardson, if for entirely different reasons). I'm not big on the basic strategy employed of buying high on QB and TE, though I do agree that Cam gains value in this rule structure. As you saw on my team, we agree on a few target players -- Maclin, CJ, Nate Washington, Jeremy Maclin and Torrey Smith are all appealing. But essentially, I'm not a fan of the basic methodology used in constructing this roster. This is a personal taste sorta-thing, and it's objectively an above average squad (if one lacking in consistency at the RB and WR).

I'd personally rather have his team, but it's too close to make a definite judgement one way or the other. He's got a deep receiving group and consistent RB play, even if S-Jax and Michael Turner are as boring an RB tandem as possible.

[colveraki]

think your team has the edge. I like your RB tandem better and WR trio better. It will be close but you have the edge.