I personally would have went Ryan over Manning, but I don't think he'll be that bad. I think minus the QB spot, your roster looks really strong. Pairing Charles and Hillis was smart, I think Hillis will see a majority of the GL carries, and vulture TDs away from Charles. Your WRs are stong as well, I have Decker rated higher then Thomas, mainly because I see thomas as the "deep threat" and not sold on Mannings arm strength yet. Overall, I give you an A-/B+. I think Ryan may have given you a higher grade though. Rate my team please?