peyton or RG3

[k_dubya]

do I trust RG3 vs new orleans or stick with Peyton vs PIT.

as an edit, the RB position gets crazy bonuses for rushing td and has easily reached yardage bonus for rushing yards. Also the longer the touchdown the more it's worth (0-25 is 6pts; 25-45 is worth 9pts; 45+ is worth 12pts.)

2nd edit. I have safer rbs going with Foster and Ridley (DAW) going with white, nelson and decker as wr

[Bherman13]

If you have some "safe" players at RB or WR, I go with RG3. His upside is incredible. If you are taking risks, ie AP, Richardson etc... Then go with Peyton.

[Deebs]

As a rookie QB playing on an offense without many weapons, I think RGIII is way overvalued.

That said, Peyton in his first game back against a tough Pitt defense s scary.

I say RGIII. I don't think either will put up big numbers, but Griffin's rushing ability may make the difference.

[11stever11]

I would go with RG3. The Redskins will need to score plenty of points against the Saints.

[mzkp54]

I say RG3. Both have risks, but I think NO will have WAS throwing the ball, and I think their WR group is underrated.

Lend a hand?
viewtopic.php?t=517247

[TruNinerFan]

Go with Manning. I want to see what RG3 can do first before I recommend starting him over Manning

[k_dubya]

ttt

[sundydrver]

RG3. It is a risk but if it works the reward is great. With Peyton it is a risk that doesnt show much reward going against PIT.

[k_dubya]

ttt

[FCNiner]

RG3