Darren McFadden for Chris Johnson

[obiwan5118]

This trade was offered to me in a standard 10 team non-PPR league. Should I pull the trigger?

Darren McFadden, RB
Peyton Hillis, RB
Reggie Wayne, WR

for

Chris Johnson, RB
Mario Manningham, WR
Kendal Hunter, RB

My teamL

Matt Ryqn QB
Chris Johnson, RB
Jamaal Charles, RB
Julio Jones, WR
Dez Bryant, WR
Aaron Hernandez, TE
Stevie Johnson, Flex
Mason Crosby, K
Broncos, Def

Reserves

Kendall Hunter, RB
Jacquizz Rodgers, RB
Andrew Luck, QB
Jonathan Stewart, RB
Ryan Williams, RB
Pierre Garcon, WR
Roy Helu, RB
Santonio Holmes, WR
Mario Manningham, WR

[AroundTheFur922]

I would absolutely take the DMC/Hillis/Wayne side of the deal.

[11stever11]

I prefer the McFadden side of the deal. Wayne is a sneaky WR2 this season, Hillis is a potential RB2, and I prefer McFadden to Johnson.

[tmoney26]

As a biased Raider fan I say take the deal. DMC is probably the biggest high risk-high reward player in the league but IF he can stay healthy dude is a beast.

[mzkp54]

I like the DMC side by a fair margin.

Lend a hand?
viewtopic.php?t=517480

[sundydrver]

I think I would keep Johnson but the rest of the trade would probably offest any loss. You would still have DMC and Charles in start. I guess I talked myself into it. I would do the trade.

[murphysxm]

I don't even think it's close. I like McFadden over CJ, Wayne over Manningham and Hillis over Hunter. Slam dunk

[sundydrver]

Really? I agree with taking trade but I have CJ has #4 RB and DMC #6, nevermind. I am still in PPR mindset. Forgot his is non-ppr.

Anyways, still take the trade

[obiwan5118]

Thanks for the advice. I took the trade.

[TheRaven]

DMC definitely has the upside..but I think CJ will have a solid, consistent year (not 2000 yards though). DMC will win you some games..but also can lose some too when he is out. I like the secondary pieces you got more too though.