Donald Brown or Willis McGahee?

[Stevis425]

Who should I start? Donald Brown or Willis McGahee?

[saur kraut & footbal]

If it's a PPR league, go with Brown. Look for the Colts to design more plays to get him the ball in space so he can use his speed; he sucks at trying to run in between tackles. Week 1 is always a crapshoot when it comes to sit/starts, but I think the safer play is McGahee in standard formats. He'll get at least 60 on the ground and maybe a TD if you're lucky. Brown gets bottled up easily, and is more of a boom or bust type of back (but he busts significantly more often than he booms).