Yes or No? Newton/Johnson trade. WHIR

[mnunez721]

Give me a yes, no, or counter offers... He Offered me: Calvin Johnson and Jay Cutler for Cam Newton and Hakeem Nicks
I know its a good trade, but I made it known to my league that I was shopping Newton, should I hold out and try to get more than Johnson?

8 Team League - ESPN Standard League (1QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1Flex, 1TE 1K 1D)
25yards/point passing, 4pts TD. 10yard/point running and catching, 6pts TD.

My Team: His Team:
Brady Rivers
Newton Cutler

McFadden Chris Johnson
Doug Martin Jamal Charles
Rashad Jennings B.J. Green-Ellis
Beanie Wells Mendenhall
Shonn Green
Donald Brown Calvin Johnson
Jordy Nelson
Julio Jones Demaryius Thomas
Hakeem Nicks Mario Manningham
Malcolm Floyd Titus Young
Miles Austin Randy Moss

Gates Jimmy Graham
Fred Davis Pettigrew

[hwell44]

I would take that deal unless you can get an elite RB (Foster, Rice, McCoy, maybe Chris Johnson depending on your feelings on him) instead. But, it doesn't get much better than C. Johnson so that's a very good deal in my mind.


Please help: viewtopic.php?t=518112

[Meugenio]

That is an easy trade. You have Brady and Cutler should improve. You are getting the best and easily most consistent WR in the game, which is much harder to find than anything else.

Please help: viewtopic.php?t=518117

[sixer03fan]

Damn. Looks like that 2 QB quandary from your last post has already resolved itself. Nice job, take the deal.

[werbs]

You have Brady. ABSOLUTELY take the deal. You already have Julio, too. Take it.

Help me out:
viewtopic.php?t=518151

[Bballneverstops]

Considering you have Brady and Newton this could only help. However, I might try to get Charles from him or make a trade with another team to get a better RB.

Help
viewtopic.php?t=517984