Jimmy Graham and Malcom Floyd for Jamaal Charles?

[OrangeBlood]

STARTERS:
QB Tony Romo
RB Darren Sproles, BJGE
WR Calvin Johnson, A.J. Green
TE Jimmy Grahm
FLX Cedric Benson
D/ST Lions
K Dan Bailey

BENCH:
QB RGIII
RB Shonn Greene, C.J. Spiller, Jonathan Dweyer
WR Malcom Floyd
TE Greg Olsen
D/ST Cowboys

As you can see I'm needy for a RB1. But then again, Graham is probably my 2nd best player. Your opinion?

[11stever11]

I like the idea of trading for Charles however this is a bit to much to pay. I think Floyd could emerge as a WR3 this season. Graham is also my #1 TE this season.

[garretterik]

I need to know if this is PPR before deciding. I see Graham as being huge in ppr this year. And I think your RBs Sproles, BJGE, and Benson will be solid in ppr format. So, I don't make this trade if ppr.
If this is a standard format it is a little trickier because you have 4 RBs who are all lower tier guys. I think JCharles is an upgrade and you have Olsen as a solid replacement TE (FYI never draft 2 TEs or 2 Def). I think JCHarles is a significant upgrade from what you got in a standard format. Floyd is irrelevant, and you have a serviceable TE replacement. The big question is what to make over the Chiefs and Charles this year. I just posted on another thread I wouldn't be surprised if he finished top 5, or outside of top 30. So, I think I would stay away from this trade in standard format, but it is a little bit closer.
Help me:
viewtopic.php?t=518213

[OrangeBlood]

Thanks for the feedback. It is standard, not PPR.
If you don't like that trade, he also has McFadden on the block. See anyone you would offer up for him?