I'm a little biased because I have a HUGE man crush on Harvin! Let's see if I can use the numbers and rational to justify this choice:
I have Harvin over Maclin definitely based on cumulative rank:
With RBs, I have Gerhart as the highest of that group:
So with it being up to Harvin vs. Gerhart, I have to lean toward Harvin, but you can probably flip a coin and be ok with either guy. Jacksonville's run defense doesn't project to be very good and I only see AP getting 5-8 touches in this game.
My full cumulative rankings can be found via my Twitter page in my signature.
And mind checking my decisions and letting me know if you'd do anything differently?http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=19&t=518231