QB start PPR

[mattk89]

First time poster so hope I do it right! Should I look for Luck with Luck, Russell Wilson, or Alex Smith?

[Indibuck]

Welcome to the Cafe.

Of the three QBs, I like Luck's upside the best.

[stomperrob]

Welcome aboard - and I agree with Luck, def has the most talent - it remains to be seen how good Wilson is in a regular season game whereas Luck is one of the most NFL ready QB's to come out in a while. Still, Luck may experience some growing pains and the Colts are in a rebuilding mode so it make take a while for that offense to gel and it may turn out they don't have all the pieces yet to succeed - keep in mind that even Peyton Manning didn't look that great in his first season.

[mattk89]

Thank you! I really like the up side of both Luck and Wilson but hard to go into 1st week unproven. That's my main concern. And they are all so close together on all the projections it's just a quagmire! Looking at experience and the fact that San Fran vs Green Bay may end up being a shoot-out that takes away San Fran's option to run, have to score to keep up with Mr. Rodgers. Does anyone think it will make a difference if Lynch is in the line up? If he doesn't play Mr. Wilson will have extra responsibilities. At least I still have 2 days to figure it out...LOL.

[Devil Doc]

Out of the three, Wilson probably has the better match up, Arizona's defense is definitly the weakest of the 3, followed by Green Bay then Chicago. All three are on the road, and of the three, I would rank them Smith, Wilson, Luck. I don't care how NFL ready Luck is, the Bears defense IN Chicago will be probably one of the tougher Ds he'll see all year. Smith is going up against a Packers team who was worst in the NFL for defending the pass, even though they led the league in INTs. Your safest bet IMO would be Smith, followed by Wilson.