Got offered McGahee for my K.Smith - should I accept? WHIR

[NFL1527]

Hey guys, I'm in a 12-team PPR League.

Been offered McGahee for my Kevin Smith. A week ago this would've been an instant accept but now I'm not too sure as Smith exploded week 1, whereas McGahee didn't do much and even got a TD stolen by Moreno. If you were me would you accept, or reject and hold on to K.Smith? thanks...WHIR

[16FAC]

I'm in the same dilemma but I think you are getting more in that trade. I don't know, can Smith stay healthy? Will DET go with Leshour once he comes back or will theys stay with the hot back. If Smith puts up solid numbers against SF (I doubt he will) then he may be in the RB1 slot all year. Its a tuff one but I'd say that you won't move him if he stinks it up next week. You may have to accept it now. Either way you are doing alright in that trade IMHO!

Please hit mine
viewtopic.php?t=519097

[rclement3915]

I'd sell high. Smiths had durability issues in the past, and leshoure is ginna eat into his touches in week 3.


viewtopic.php?t=519081

[thepsychic]

Keep Kevin Smith. He may be injury prone, but I'm not high on McGahee... unless you need a solid flex play with a low ceiling.

help: viewtopic.php?t=519101

[Radelaide]

if you want to get rid of K Smith when the goings good, maybe look a stealing a higher ranked RB that had a crap week 1