Dynasty League Andre for K. Smith and...WHIR

[shoof08]

I was offered Kevin Smith, Crabtree and a draft pick of some kind for Andre Johnson in my dynasty league.

Dynasty League: Standard scoring, 10 team league, Two renewal (3 year) contracts each year. Draft picks are kept for 3 years also unless dropped. Years left are in the parentheses.

My Team:
QB - Rivers (2)
RB - Forte (2)
RB - Bush (1)
WR/TE - A. Johnson (3)
WR/TE - Welker (2)
WR/TE - M. Austin (1)
WR/RB - D. Sproles (1)
BN - Torrey Smith (3)
BN - T. Gonzalez (1)
BN - P. Thomas (3)
BN - D. Wilson (3)
BN - K. Wright (3)
BN - R. Jennings (3)
BN - Cutler (3)
K - Baiey (1)

His Team:
QB - Ryan (3)
RB - Rice (3)
RB - Richardson (3)
WR/TE - Colston (1)
WR/TE - D. Jackson (2)
WR/TE - Gates (1)
WR/RB - Ridley (3)
BN - K. Smith (3)
BN - Meachem (3)
BN - Crabtree (3)
BN - Hardesty (1)
BN - M. Bush (1)
BN - Flacco (1)
BN - S. Hill (1)
K - Crosby (2)

At first glance I didn't like it at all, but considering everything the trade isnt all that bad. Leave a link and I'll help out. Thanks in advance for the help

[shoof08]

bump

[goose in my step]

i wouldnt do it. if anything i would ask for more since andre looked really good in the first game and if can stay healthy is #2 wr behind megaton

viewtopic.php?t=519109

[LWCrunner55]

I'd pass on it. Andre is too good and he helps you win now. Unless it is a high draft pick I wouldn't do it

[shoof08]

The potential pick would probably in round 2 hopefully round 1 or both. We don't know the draft order until the season is finished since its based on the end of the year standings.

[shoof08]

Any other thoughts on this?

[oxhammer]

Tough one because both Smith and Johnson are so injury prone. The winner is the owner who doesn't get the injury. Basically, I think it comes down to this. Do you want to set up your team to win this year? If so, explore other trades. Counter with a non-injury prone running back and maybe even exclude the draft pick to get it done. If you want to set up your team to win next year, it's not a bad trade.

viewtopic.php?t=519629