Would you take this trade? Should I counter?

[Naps621]

I will post my whole lineup so you can see depth, talent, etc.
QBs
Mike Vick
Joe Flacco
RBs
Frank Gore
MJD
Stevan Ridley
Kevin Smith
Jonathan Stewart
WRs
Brandon Lloyd
Calvin Johnson
Jeremy Maclin
Mike Wallace


TE
Jared Cook
K
Alex Henery
DEF
Philadelphia

A guy in my league is proposing a trade for Stevan Ridley, he is offering Willis McGahee and Victor Cruz. This is a standard league, not PPR. Should I take it or counter...advice?

His lineup is:
QB
RGIII
RBs
Ray Rice
Demarco Murray
Peyton Hillis
Willis Mcgahee
Rashard Mendenhall
Alfred Morris
WR
Justin Blackmon
TE
Greg Olsen

[B3N1ZJAM1N]

how many of each position can you start?

[Naps621]

1 QB
2 RB
2 WR
1 Flex
1 TE
1 K
1 Def

[goodwidp]

I think your pretty strong at WR so I would hold onto Ridley. Him and McGahee are probably pretty equal in terms of potential points this year, but McGahee is more susceptible to injury, especially as the season progresses, so I think Ridley carries less risk.

Thanks for your help.

[KELLYLEAK]

I would take it, but I'm high on V Cruz and McGahee- if he can stay healthy. You could counter with Jones-Drew who i think will get hurt after a long holdourt but that's up to you. Overall i think that's a good deal for you. Please help with mine.


viewtopic.php?t=519525