bradshaw/dougie/l.moore vs charles/beanie/a.brown

[Dirt McGirt]

Title says it all

I get Charles Beanie and Antonio Brown and Im giving up bradshaw, doug martin, and lance moore.

We start 2 rbs. My stable is mcfadden brasdshaw and doug martin. It is nice having the depth with martin or bradshaw on the bench but the thought of mcfadden and charles in the same backfield is too sexy to pass up. Basically the bottom line is im losing my depth in the backfield. I am already am a Hillis owner so I have the handcuff in place.

Please let me know your thoughts. I will reply to your question if you paste it in the reply window

[Dirt McGirt]

UPDATE:

owner is balking on this one. He now wants stevie johnson instead of l.moore

so it would now be bradshaw marting stevie j for charles beanie and brown

[finnbhennach]

Since you have hills as a back up for charles, im leaning towards accepting the trade.
I like charles over bradshaw, especially as the year goes on, and brown over moore.
however, you may want to consider throwing beanie back to the waiver pool.

[whale59250]

Do you think you could make a counter offer and not give up Martin and let him keep Beanie? I really like Brown this season and I think he will be the Steelers top fantasy option at WR and of course Charles over Bradshaw is a no brainer. I would hate to lose Martin this early in the season. He put up some impressive stats for his first game and Beanie simply did not and he's got Williams breathing down his neck to be the starting back. I would need to know who your WR's, how many start and if there is a flex to tell you if I would accept the proposed trade.

[goose in my step]

dont do it. beanie is toxic

[whale59250]

Did not see that balked on the trade before my post. I say no for sure now. I don't see much of an upgrade if any of brown over Johnson and like everyone else has said stay away from beanie.

Could you please help with mine:
viewtopic.php?t=519639

[Dirt McGirt]

dont do it. beanie is toxic

Haha on yea i agree. Beanie sucks. He is just a throw in to make it an even position for position trade.


There is no flex in the league so having 3 good rbs is only important on bye week / injury.

Current line up

RB - DMC
RB - Bradshaw (dougie on the bench as #3 rb)
wr - julio
wr - torrey smith
wr stevie johnson (lance moore #4 wr)

after trade it would be
RB - DMC
RB - Charles (Hillis handcuffed already)
WR - julio
WR - torrey smith
WR - antonio brown (lance moore #4 wr)
(issue with this line up is Beanie would be my 3rb.)
Thanks for the replys. And if you have a question post your link and ill help

[Naps621]

I agree with one of the previous posts above, see if you can get Brown and Charles for Bradshaw or Martin and Moore.
I think Charles is an upgrade from either Bradshaw or Martin
and even though Moore is a target for Brees, I think Brown is set to have a big season


Take a look at my question, any advice is always welcome!!
viewtopic.php?f=19&t=519514

[KELLYLEAK]

Thanks for the help with mine. I would not do this deal. I think D Martin > Charles. Bradshaw > Wells (terrible) and A. Brown is not worth giving up Martin and Bradshaw. Charles is still an injury risk with his knee injury from last year. Beanie is brutal. If you're going to move someone I'd shop bradhsaw over Martin. But I'd stand pat.