I don't know...if you could try and get a less-risky RB in the process, I'd be willing to give up Mathews, but don't undervalue him too far with this trade. See if you can sub out Finley for a lesser WR (one that might have a good game here or there) and a RB1 (not a top-5 obviously, but definitely someone better than Wells).
Things I like from this trade:
- Getting rid of both Chargers RBs...neither of which I want the rest of the season, especially with Mathews injury history
- Getting Gronk
- Getting Thomas
Things I don't like from this trade:
- Only getting Beanie Wells...as much as I don't like Mathews, he at least has better upside than Mathews, while having the same concern with injury
- Giving up both Colston and Maclin
- ...again...Beanie Wells...
Help weigh in on mine? Which trade offer would you shoot for?: http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=18&t=519842