Jay Cutler or Eli Manning? WHIR

[Smoakland Hammer]

I'm thinking Eli bounces back against TB on Sunday. Part of me wants to roll with Jay tonight though just for the fun of it. What do you guys think?

[StrikerBeaver99]

I'd go with Cutler. Rodgers had a great game against them, and Cam didn't do much against TB.

[sundydrver]

Though one, safer bet is Eli but I would go with Cutler for the upside.

[GreenBowlPackers]

I'd roll with Eli, simply because you know Charles Woodson is going to be all over Marshall the entire game, and I think Woodson matches up well against big, physical receivers. That leaves Cutler throwing to Jeffers, Kellen Davis, Earl Bennett... I dont think that matches the upside of Eli with 2 big play receivers going up against Tampa - who despite doing well against Cam, really didnt look that great to me. I just think Carolina is that overrated.

Pitta v James Jones v Meachem?
viewtopic.php?t=519862

[bigvans36]

Cutler could go off against a mediocre Green Bay pass defense but I don't see Eli having two below average games in a row.

[kjmiller127]

Id go with J. Cutler. San Fran with Alex smith lit them up last week, J. Cutler should beast out

[TeamDanimal]

I would go with Eli. Cruz had a few dropped balls last game that could have changed the game had he caught them and also would have helped ppl with Eli in their pools as well. I am sure Cruz won't be dropping any balls this week