Two trades on the table please advise

[hevak]

PPR League

Trade #1
Give: Frank Gore, Andre Johnson = Get: Chris Johnson, Reggie Wayne

Trade #2
Give; Frank Gore = Get: Jamaal Charles

I personally like trade #1 I am high on Wayne and Chris Johnson has good upside. Thoughts? post your link I will return the favor, thanks.

My team:
QB Aaron Rogers
WR Andre Johnson
WR Hakeem Nicks
WR Marques Colston
RB MJD
RB Spiller
TE Vernon Davis
Flex Frank Gore or Shonne Greene or Randal Cobb or Anquan Boldin

[cbrowns]

First, thanks for answering mine (cbrowns, trying to decide to trade RG3 for marshall or nelson).

I don't like either of these trades actually.

First trade: Gore is better than CJ, and who knows if CJ turns it around? Not a great O line or QB to let him succeed. And Andre should be fine, not sure if wayne will keep it up. Even if Wayne slightly better, doesn't outweigh gore being better than CJ.

Second trade: Charles has come back nicely, but he's not running like Gore. I think he' s a strong flex play for you, better than Charles.

Hope that helps

[fescobar]

#1 awful

#2 I'd consider it, but like how the 49ers are using Gore, so I'd stand pat

[Mean One]

Neither of those trades are good for you. I would stand pat and look for better value in return for either Gore or A.Johnson.

[2011wahoo]

Reggie wayne has absolutely ZERO upside. I personally would not make either one of those trades, but then again CJ could breakout and become an absolute stud..big if though.

[hevak]

Thanks guys I will think about it more.

[JP555]

no and no

[jeduardomalo]

It's definitely a no no for both trades