Should i trade for Brandon Marshall ?? WHIR

[Wakbrder87]

the guy who has Brandon Marshall is struggling at RB besides Arian Foster
Arian Foster, Fred Jackson, Ryan Williams, Toby Gerhart, Isaac Redman, Johnathan Dwyer

I have Lesean McCoy, Reggie Bush, Ryan Matthews, Rashard Mendenhall, Michael Turner.

The reason i say hes weak at RB is because Fred Jackson might have trouble getting back on the field with how C.J Spiller is playing.

althought it be considered trade r!@# hes in the desperate situation what do you think of the offer of Ryan Matthews, Rashard Mendenhall, Michael Turner for Foster and Marshall

if that falls thru( which is more than likely to) would you try matthews for marshall straight up?

[mgerrick]

matthews for marshall seems more fair lol. hard to tell how matthews will perform this year. maybe the SD o-line got their act together and rivers throwing it the way he did yesterday certainly helps matthews cause. With battle in the mix though im a little concerned they won't rush matthews return. then again, forte is out and bears passing game looks nice! really marshall for a big year. go for it if you need WR help.

viewtopic.php?t=520729 help out?

[jeduardomalo]

I would try offering Ryan Matthews + a low end no. 2, no. 3 receiver. The reason being, as they just said, Matthews is a coin toss, we are not sure when he will be back and even though he seems like the man in SD, he may lose some workload to Jackie Battle if he keeps performing the way he did. Try the deal Matthews - Marshall straight up, if it does not fall through, try adding a receiver.

[Footballfev]

Brandon Marshall is a stud for sure. Hard to tell if you should trade for him without knowing your whole roster. But, I think Marshall for Matthews is fair. Agree with above, you might need to throw in a wr since he would be giving up a number 1 wr and there is a lot of uncertainty with Matthews. I would sell Matthews high instead of low though. He should return next week and we'll get a chance to see what he is capable of. I would wait one week. I think Bush is overperforming. Their o-line is shit, they have a rookie qb, and they will be playing from behind a lot. His stats will go down.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=520726