Which Trade should I do? WHIR

[btsoumas]

This is my team in a 14 man ESPN Standard
QB: Cutler, Cassel
RB: AP, Charles, Martin, Morris, Jennings, Vereen
WR: Marshall, Wallace, Bowe, Moss, Little
TE: Daniels
D/ST: Bengals
K: Zuerlein

I have two trades on the board from two separate people. Which one should I pull the trigger on if any?
Trade 1
Give up: Cutler and Charles OR Martin (My choice)
Get: Vick and Mendenhall

Trade 2
Give up: Daniels and Morris
Get: Jermichael Finley and Hillis

[srlarson]

Trade 1 is terrible....Doesn't make you better.....

Trade #2 - don't think Finley upgrade is worth the downgrade to hillis......

I think i pass on both....

[ob187]

Pass on both. You aren't upgrading your roster at all.

Help me in return:
viewtopic.php?t=521183

[NeverOutNick]

Trade #1: Depends on who you feel about Cutler. I like Vick but not so much recently with injuries to his Oline and Maclin...I don't like charles so if you feel confident Vick is a significant upgrade over Cutler (They're both risky) then go for it.

Trade #2: I don't think Morris is going to be the starter all year for WAS and Rodgers hasn't got in his groove yet so if you could do Morris straight for Finley thats not a bad trade at all

[sm28185]

definitely no for trade 1. i think cutler can still bounce back from last week.

i think trade 2 is closer to being reasonable, but you're still not getting a fair shake. i agree that finley isn't enough of an upgrade to make up for you losing martin.

[goose in my step]

if u can get the other owner to add a better rb for trade 1 then u should consider. but for right now i suggest u stay with wat u have
remember lambeau is cutler's kryptonite. he should be good next week

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=521257