Looking at just RBs, he has studs getting hurt that (other than Bush) look to be losing carries to their backups. On the other hand you have guys coming back (Mathews, Leshoure, Mendenhall) with no serious competition (read: drop Dwyer) if they are able to produce. If Mathews steps up as the RB1 you drafted and Leshoure becomes a consistent top-12 guy, you're looking really good. As a Fitz owner I hope he finally keeps up the numbers as well.
Forced to choose, I'd take team 1 for this week and team 2 for the year, but any number of things could flip that around very quickly. Good luck making him eat his words!
12-team PPR [QB, 3 WR, 2 RB, TE, K, DST]: QB: Brees | WR: Green, Fitz, Austin, Floyd, Britt, Jennings | RB: Alf, Martin, TRich, Ridley, Sproles | TE: Myers | K: Bryant | DST: SF49