WHIR - Trading for D McFadden/R Mathews/T Richardson

[sm28185]

12 team H2H league, 4 pts per pass TD, 6 pts per rush/rec TD, 0.1 pts per rush/rec yard, 0.04 pts per pass yard

My team as it stands now:

QB - Drew Brees, Carson Palmer
RB - C.J. Spiller, Willis McGahee, Shonn Greene, Mike Goodson
WR - Larry Fitzgerald, A.J. Green, Denarius Moore, Nate Washington, Kevin Ogletree
TE - Antonio Gates, Fred Davis

There's a guy in my league that's desperate to get an upgrade at QB or WR. Because of injuries (albeit small ones) to my RBs, I figure I might try to get some help. His roster looks like this:

QB - Ryan Fitzpatrick, Shaun Hill
RB - Darren McFadden, Ryan Mathews, Trent Richardson, Ben Tate, Robert Turbin, Jahvid Best, Jackie Battle
WR - Jordy Nelson, Kenny Britt
TE - Aaron Hernandez, Brent Celek

Are either of these trade offers ridiculous? And/or should I consider something else?

1)
Give - Palmer, F Davis, N Washington
Get - McFadden/Mathews/Richardson, Tate

2)
Give - Palmer, F Davis, D Moore
Get - McFadden/Mathews/Richardson, Tate

3)
Give - Palmer, Gates, N Washington
Get - McFadden/Mathews/Richardson, Tate

4)
Give - Palmer, Gates, D Moore
Get - McFadden/Mathews/Richardson, Tate

WHIR - post links in response

[sm28185]

bump