S. Rice, J Simpson, or G Tate??? Help.

[Enrique Aguilar]

Sydney Rice just came on the waiver wire. I was thinking of picking up Jerome Simpson as a possible flex or bye week WR fill but now I'm looking at Rice. Who has the best up side? Also contemplating Golden Tate.
Yahoo .5PPR plus return yards 12 team.

Thanks for the help.
I will help you if I can.

QB- Brady
WR- D Jackson
WR- D Thomas
WR- AJ Green
RB- M Lynch
RB- D Murry
TE- D Pitta
W/R/T- R Cobb
K- Tucker
DEF- Pats


BN-A Morris (RB)
BN- K Winslow (TE)
BN- Leshore (RB)
BN- D Amendola(WR)
BN-
BN- P. Garcon (WR)

[Enrique Aguilar]

Is this a no brainier or a toss up?

Help please.