Giants Defense? WHIR

[Dr. Mundo]

I'd like to hear your opinions on this defense.

NYG vs Philly - Philly has been turning the ball over like a cook turns pancakes. They do have the ability to score big, but i think Vick will be pressured based on what happened in the last Giants game. Most defenses are gone besides the Giants. Notables leftovers are: Vikings vs Det, Broncos vs Oak, Packers vs NO, Cowboys vs Chi

Also for a different league, would you play the Ravens vs Browns or the Cardinals vs Mia?

Thanks WHIR

[archie814]

First, your DEF options this week are pretty bad in general. Obviously, so of them will score decently, but none really stand out. The NYG DEF scares me a little because PHI can score (whether they've done a lot of it yet or not). Also, they were impressive last week against CAR, but in the first two weeks, 24 to DAL and 34 to TB, with little-to-no turnovers. I think they are more like weeks 1 and 2, than they are like week 3. For that reason, I'd play DAL this week. They are an underrated DEF and they seem to play lower scoring games in general than NYG. They have allowed the least amount of yards through the first 3 weeks, and the least amount of passing yards as well. Cutler is just as turnover prone as Vick...

The other league you a fine either way. Arizona has looked great on DEF and MIA is missing Bush, and that's why I'd play them. However, I expect the Ravens to do well also (coming from a Browns fan).

Good luck.

Here's mine: viewtopic.php?t=522880

[GreenBowlPackers]

I would slightly rank the NYG's D matchup ahead of the Cowboys' matchup. Both teams have QBs that are prone to a lot of mistakes, but Cutler's mistakes usually arent as castostrophic as Vick's. Giants should easily force 3 TOs that game and I dont see PHI putting up more than 20 pts or so.

In the other league, it all depends on Reggie Bush. With Reggie Bush, the Fins have a more complete ground game that can give the Cards fits. If he's hurt, limited, or whatever, I'd start the Cards D. If not, start the Ravens D.

Mine:
viewtopic.php?t=522818