need opinions of this trade before commish vetos!

[joe0523]

I have made a trade with another team in my league and we have been getting alot of grief from the other teams in the league as they feel the trade is lopsided and unfair. The trade is as follows:

Darren Mcfadden for Pierre Garcon, Doug Martin and Stevan Ridley

The team giving up Mcfadden is 0-3 and has alot of holes in his roster therefore is trying to trade a tier 1 player for several tier 2 or tier 3 players to fill his weaknesses. Please respond with your opinions of this as the commissioner is trying to decide whether or not to veto this trade due to the complaints from 2 or 3 other team owners. I dont feel that this trade is lopsided and feel that it is a good trade for both teams involved, but maybe im wrong. Thanks for the help!!

[dweenmachine]

I don't think it's a lopsided deal at all. McFadden is an injury concern. Martin is a good high tier 2/low tier 1 RB and Ridley is borderline tier 2... Garcon is borderline tier 2 as well, but like you said, he's giving up one tier 1 player for to fill the holes in his overall roster. You're getting one good player who has a penchant for getting injured.
Do I think you're getting a good deal, sure, but it's not lopsided.

[joe0523]

thanks for the reply! anyone else have any thoughts??