Spiller and Brandon Marshall for DMC or AP (WHIR)

[mycuccismells]

Thinking of offering up Spiller and Brandon marshall in an attempt to get either Adrian Peterson or McFadden (2 different owners).

1. Would you prefer to get McFadden or AP in return??
2. Am i giving up too much for this?? My lineup is below and essentially Antonio Brown would slide into Marshalls spot. THe question becomes whether the downgrade from Marshall to Brown is more/less than the upgrade from Spiller to McFadden/AP

Fitzgerald
Marshall
Antonio Brown
Torrey Smith
DHB
Nate Washington
Chris Johnson
Spiller
Reggie Bush
McGahee
Draughn

[webba495]

Spiller is a beast (should be the #1 back when healthy) and McFadden is injury prone. I would not make that trade because you would be giving up too much.