Vick or Ponder?

[jstjohn]

Vick is obviously the better QB but goes up against the tough Steelers this week, while Ponder faces the Titans, who have given up a lot of points to opposing QB's so far. Who would YOU start and why?

[nightfox422]

I have the same 2 guys, and I am sticking with Vick for now.

And by sticking with Vick, I mean I am starting him and hoping do does really good so I can trade him

viewtopic.php?t=524453

[Skimo77]

Vick no doubt in my mind between these two... Ponder has been solid but has no where near the potential that Vick has. I'd say Ponder's ceiling is Vick's floor. Ponder had a terrible fantasy week last year against a week Detroit defense.

[rmsanger]

Vick has way more upside but a much lower floor than Ponder so I guess it depends. I'm rolling with Vick in another league cause my opponent has a crazy good team so I will need the upside just to compete.