Vick or Luck? PPR

[petem42]

torn between these two...

Vick against Steelers strong run and pass D
or
Luck against Packers weak pass D

Vick is higher in all player rankings, but Matthew Berry has Vick on his hate list and Luck on his love list.

[Senator Blutarsky]

Vick for me. Luck will still be on his back a lot IMO.

[16FAC]

I'd go with Luck! They will be playing catch-up 6 minutes into the 1st quarter and Luck has shown that he has the arm and accuracy to find receivers. Plus Brees lit em up last week so Luck should fair half as well as Brees this week which I would take any day! Vick has way too many picks to TD's to spark my interest at this point. Plus as stingy as PITT D will be this week (Troy and James back) Vick may not even finish the game!

please hit mine
viewtopic.php?t=524478

[eaglesfan17]

id roll the dice on vick

[oo3]

I agree w/ everyone. Vick is the way to go.

viewtopic.php?t=524493

[Skimo77]

Vick for sure, GB has a very opportunistic defense... aka pick happy.

[gregtucker87]

Id Go luck on this one. The only bad game he has had so far was his first start against a VERY tough Bears defense, and this game against GB, luck will be playing catch up the whole game and will be throwing alot of passes. Im sure he will have an INT or two but im saying the same thing about Vick. And I just dont trust Vick. He make's alot of bad decisions and is one QB scramble away from a broken something. I say Luck on this one. Good luck!

[tantrix1969]

I'd go Luck on this one, either Vick plays conservative and they don't turn over ball(and also not put up alot of qb points) or he's his old self with multiple turnovers